The Rules

Silas is a happy little guy, as long as the world operates 100% according to his rules.

Some of these rules are transparent to me. I try my best to go along with them when I can, even when it’s inconvenient.

Some of them are indecipherable. I’m sure there are reasons and patterns for these things, but I don’t know them.

The most important set of rules is Silas’s long list of things that are safe and not safe. It’s a long, extremely specific, and very arbitrary list.

Last Tuesday at the park, for instance. We were at Silas’s favorite park. This is one of very few outdoors places where he is 100% happy. As long as we’re on the trails and not in the parking lot, he’s better with people here than almost anywhere. His leash manners are better. He’s more willing to eat. Even here, I managed to terrify him.

What did I do that was so bad? I broke the rules.

I walked him twenty feet off of his usual route, to get to a trash can so that I could throw away his poop bag. He spent the entire twenty feet (during which time we were within sight of his regular route) flattened to the ground, clawing desperately at the dirt, trying to turn me back to the safe route. This was with a dose of his short-term anti-anxiety medication.

The good thing about the rules is that they allow for a lot of randomness. Once you are on “the list,” you’re on. The park that is usually closed to cars? Gets a free pass for the odd car driving by. The pet store? It’s okay for people to pet him. Parking lots? Not nice, but infinitely less evil than any other place we might see a car.

The bad thing about the rules is that, especially as Silas gets older, it is almost impossible for me to change them. Which is, I know, typical dog stuff. That’s why puppy socialization is so important, and now that Silas is two and a half that window is long closed. But even in the realm of normal dog training, Silas’s fear of the “bad things” is so strong that I can’t break through. There is no trainable distance that we can be from a moving car. There is no audible-to-humans sidewalk noise that I can use as a base for counter-conditioning. There is not one step on the scary trail that isn’t so stressful Silas would refuse a treat.

I’ve been resisting for a while now, but I think it might be time to put him on some daily medication. My hope is that this will loosen up “the rules” enough that I can put some things on the “good” list. I’ve got nothing to work with right now.

6 thoughts on “The Rules

    1. She’s pleased, but thinks he should probably be moving faster with the amount of work I’m doing. We’re going to try some Prozac for a while and see if that helps him. If it makes him dopey or sedated we’ll take him back off.


  1. Oh darn, that is such a tough decision for you to make and I know you’ve given it hours and hours of thought…I do hope the Prozac will loosen Silas up a little bit and put some flexibility into the rules…I admire you so much…I don’t know what I’d do if faced with these rigid rules


  2. Poor Silas. I thought Gretel was a nervous nelly but her rules are pretty simple compared to his. Her rule for other dogs is pretty much “stay away”. For people it is “stay away” or “I am curious for a second but could really give a rats ass about you…so DON’T you try to follow me as a walk away even though I am cute and irresistible”. She IS nervous in many situations but she just gets tense. Like you though, I still want it to get better even though I know her window of significant change is pretty much closed. I hope Silas is able to make some progress so neither of you have to be so stressed out.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s